Wednesday, 3/7/18 — Bridging the Gap Between Doing and Knowing

There was a classic Doctor Who episode from the 1970s where the science-fiction heroes encounter a group of colonists on another world who have long since forgotten their roots and reverted to a primitive life. The people of that civilization had an odd gesture as a way of greeting each other: They would touch their throat, their shoulder, and their hip. The titular Doctor notices this and comments: “That gesture you did . . . It’s presumably to ward off evil. It’s interesting because it’s also the sequence for checking the seals on a Starfall Seven spacesuit. And what makes that particularly interesting is that you don’t know what a Starfall Seven spacesuit is, do you?”

He was, indeed, correct; the colonists’ ancestors had traveled to this planet via a spaceship where you had to check the seals, and that gesture was passed down long after the underlying technology passed away. The colonists had been devoid of tech for so long, they continued to make these gestures without understanding why they did them or why they were important.

Today’s readings talk about the old laws and Jesus’ relationship with them. It’s a fairly challenging topic, and it’s one I tackled in my column on these readings last Lent. Honestly, as I reflected on these readings, I dreaded a bit having to come up with something new to say.

But as I considered this bit of Scripture again, that Doctor Who episode sprang to mind. Being a Catholic means doing a lot of things that are strange to outsiders. These range from odd gestures (like the Sign of the Cross or genuflecting) to unusual actions (such as fasting or abstaining from meat) to beliefs not held by the rest of the world (like teachings on capital punishment or birth control).

Thinking about Christ’s teachings today, these two ideas started to come together. Jesus is talking about his role in Judaic law, and how he is instrumental in unifying the expectations of old and bringing humanity together in union with God, Tradition, and each other.

And as I look back on our Traditions, our teachings, our gestures, our actions, I find myself wondering. They’re obviously important, but do we know why they’re important?

You probably know the reasons behind more common actions, like the Sign of the Cross. But do you know the reason behind blessing yourself with holy water as you come into Mass? (If so, do you actually think about the underlying reason when you do so?) Do you know what days of the year that entryway holy water is not supposed to be available?

Do you know why we fast during this season of Lent, or abstain from meat on Fridays?

When we say “and with your spirit” during Mass, do you know why we do so and what it means?

Do you know why and when it’s appropriate to bow, genuflect, or kneel when you enter Mass or a chapel?

You probably have heard the phrase “Lamb of God” a lot. Do you know what that means or what it’s referring to?

What about those Latin phrases and verses we recite, especially during Lent?

If you’ve uttered or heard the phrase “Catholics don’t believe in divorce,” do you understand what that’s saying, what it says about our understanding of the institution of marriage, and how it might be a bit misleading?

It’s not essential you understand every aspect of the faith. I certainly don’t. (My wife still surprises me occasionally with tidbits of insight into what the priest is doing or saying at certain points of the Mass.) And it’s certainly possible to go through life as a fully realized, deeply faithful Catholic without understanding every nuance. Many saints and martyrs devoted their lives to God with little interest in the more “academic” side of the Church, relying on their deep faiths as they followed Christ.

But it can be very rewarding to realize that pretty much everything we do has some kind of meaning. Failing to understand that meaning – or, at least, being keenly aware of the fact that there is a larger meaning – can carry its own risks.

First, it keeps you from a deeper connection to God and our Faith. If the blessing with holy water is supposed to remind us of our baptism, how can that gesture be doing its job if it never makes you think of what baptism is or does, and what our baptismal promises offer and expect?

Second, failing to think about this stuff leaves you open to having your faith shaken. Imagine if some outsider says, “Why do you have to go to Mass every week . . . even when you’re on vacation?!” If you don’t have a good justification in your own mind, it’ll be really easy for the Devil to wheedle into that chink in your spiritual armor, prompting you to miss Mass when it’s not convenient – perhaps ultimately skipping it even when it is.

Finally, if you don’t understand what we’re doing and why, you can’t explain it to others. That puts a damper on efforts to defend and spread the Church. (You know why that’s important according to our faith, right?)

During this Lenten season – perhaps today, or the next time you attend Mass – really think about the Faith and the Church. Is there some aspect of what you’re believing or doing that you don’t understand? Or perhaps something you’re not doing in Mass that you know you do at other times of the year? (Have you noticed a lack of music in recent weeks, or the absence of phrases we use the rest of the year?)

If you find something you don’t fully understand, research it! The Internet is a great resource, but be careful about sites that may not be speaking from a position of belief or understanding of the Catholic faith. (I tend to find Catholic.org a reliable resource, but — as ever — I recommend taking everything you read online with a grain of salt (including this column!).

For questions about teachings or beliefs, the Catechism of the Catholic Church is invaluable.

If you’re feeling pretty confident about your knowledge in most things, think of something a bit esoteric that you comprehend. Can you explain it so that someone else can understand it? They say you don’t really know something until you can explain it in terms a child would grasp.

When I came into the Church, one of the first books I read was Catholicism for Dummies. As a result, I got to learn a lot of the basics about the Faith with the eyes of a 30-something-year-old; I never had to bridge the gap of what I was doing with what I knew. I don’t necessarily recommend that, but — if you haven’t already — I do recommend trying to shore up your actions with real knowledge. Ours is a rich and rewarding faith. With a little effort, you can grow closer to it and to God. Otherwise, you risk going through motions you don’t understand, like a space colonist gesturing to a long-absent spacesuit.

Today’s readings: Dt 4:1,5-9; Ps 147:12-13,15-16,19-20; Mt 5:17-19

About the Author

Despite being a professional writer and editor for over 15 years, Steven Marsh is more-or-less winging it when it comes to writing about matters of faith. Steven entered the church in 2005, and since then he's been involved with various ministries, including Pre-Cana marriage prep for engaged couples, religious education for kindergarteners, and Stephen Ministry's one-on-one caregiving. Steven lives in Indiana with his wife and son. Despite having read the entirety of the Bible and the Catechism of the Catholic Church, he's still surprised at elements he rediscovers or reflects upon in new ways. The more Steven learns about the faith, the less he feels he knows; he's keen to emphasize that any mistakes are his own.

Author Archive Page

15 Comments

  1. Very insightful, Steve. You’ve just inspired me to read up some more on the “academics” side of the faith, realizing that there a lot of things I do, I do instinctively without knowing and understanding the underlying reason. Thanks for your message today, and may God bless you always.

  2. A beautiful reflection Steve, thanks! Makes me feel that i should go back to the basics in order to understand my Faith more fully. I cant even answer some of the questions you have asked! The Catholic is so rich in Faith and we need to tap all that we can get.There is so much to learn.

  3. Thank you so much Steve.Each year,I always strive to add to the deposit of my Catholic faith by doing more than I did the previous year-including reading,prayers,etc. The faith is so vast and rewarding that it seems like I know nothing. May God continue to revive the fire within my heart,Amen.

  4. I really enjoyed reading your post today. We take our faith so much for granted especially us cradle Catholics! I’m going to go check up on a few things right now…….

  5. Thanks Steve. I think of my faith as a life long lesson and you reminded me we are never to old to learn. God Bless you

  6. Very nice use of contemporary culture to inspire a deeper reflection on today’s readings. (I confess to a momentary digression as I wondered which doctor was featured in that episode?)

  7. I look forward to every Wednesday and your post. Enlighting that’s how you make me feel. You are so correct how much we cradle Catholics especially take for granted. Thank you from a 70 year old.

  8. Hey Steven,

    You bring up a good point, what should we know? And then ask yourself, why am I Catholic?

    Mark

  9. Nicely written. You’re a very knowledgeable writer, obviously. Maybe next time you actually share why we perform some of the traditions you mentioned, instead of keeping that knowledge to you yourself.

  10. Steven, very good reflection. Gives me several more things to pay attention to. Peace be with you.

  11. thanks Steve! that was truly insightful. that introduction caught my attention and I read your article to the end. Ad astra per aspera!

  12. Thank you for the comments, everyone! They mean a lot to me.

    Paul, is there any particular bit I mentioned that you’re deeply curious by? I did offer one example in the course of my reflection of answering my own question (how blessing ourselves with holy water before we go to Mass is to remind us of our baptism, of what baptism is, and what it promises). Really, the whole point of my article this week was to hopefully inspire readers to research this material themselves. And, to be honest — outside of the most superficial level — just about any one of my rhetorical questions could be the basis for a reflection on its own (and my posts tend to run long as it is). But if one of the tidbits particularly provoked your curiosity, I can probably provide a brief overview/summary as I understand it or find a link that goes into a bit more detail.

    Baker, the Doctor in question was the Fourth Doctor, played by Tom Baker. The episode was Part 1 of “The Face of Evil,” from 1977. (I didn’t want to go too far babbling about Doctor Who despite my great fondness for the show.)

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.