Thursday, August 8, 2019 – Doubting faith … 1 tap at a time

How many taps does it take to draw water from a rock?

What was Moses thinking as he stood in front of his people on that hot, dry day in the desert, his staff raised high above his head?

Fresh off a prayer and a promise from God that he could perform a miracle and draw fresh water from the rock, Moses must have had a momentary attack of doubt.

The Lord had told him to strike the rock with his staff and watch as He satisfied the thirst of his people.

Simple instruction. Tap the rock!

But Moses, in a momentary lapse of faith, tapped the rock twice (just to be sure?).

The water flowed, but God became angry.

This is the reason Moses was ultimately denied entry into the Promised Land. Most people think it’s because he tossed the tablets of the Ten Commandments into the midst of the riot when he descended from the mountain.

But in reality, this scene in today’s Old Testament is the reason. (By the way, this makes a great trivia question)!

One might think God was cracking down a little too hard on Moses. After all, it’s just a stick and a rock.

But, when you dig a little deeper, it was more than that.

Think about the journey of Moses … from slave of Egypt to near death in the desert, from a new life with sheep herders on the other side of the sand to sudden prophet of God after an encounter with a burning bush.

Along the way, he is confronted by many tests of his faith and his endurance. Each time, the Lord provided. He was constantly second guessing his own abilities to deliver the Hebrews out of Egypt, and each time, the Lord gave him the right words to say and the right things to do.

How many of us are in this same boat? How many of us doubt that we have the gifts and the skills to evangelize our family, friends, co-workers and fellow parishioners? How many of us sneak into the back of the church and then sneak out early in order to avoid a conversation?

How many of us fear that when the time comes to answer a question of faith, we will be dumbstruck and unable to answer?

Perhaps this is a call to spend a little more time learning about our faith and our Church teachings so that we can do a better job of answering a question … keeping in mind that a single conversation – a single word from you or me – can be the start of a miraculous conversion within an individual who has turned to us for help.

Back to Moses.

Why did God crack down so hard for turning a single tap order into a doubt-filled double tap on that rock?

Perhaps it is because Moses had been through so much that he – above anyone else present that day – should have had the faith to let God work his miracle as he wished.

What’s that saying from Luke’s Gospel? Much will be required of the person entrusted with much, and still more will be demanded of the person entrusted with more.

Clearly, Moses was being held to a higher standard. Perhaps God wanted to set an example.

Either way, a similar incident is recounted in today’s Gospel, where we see that Peter has incredible faith to be able to directly and succinctly declare that Jesus is the Son of God. He gets a lot of praise from Jesus, who promises to build his Church on the faith of Peter.

And then … just a few lines later … Jesus tells that same apostle to “Get behind me Satan.”

Peter had experienced the same moment of doubt when he questioned God’s plan to permit his Son to be judged and crucified.

Jesus tells Peter, he is thinking like a man, rather than thinking as God does.

How many of us spend so many useless hours thinking as men do, instead of keeping our eyes on the prize and realizing that God has a plan, he works in mysterious ways and we should not worry so much about our own abilities to let Him work miracles through the things we say and do?

It all comes down to faith.

And the strength to tap that rock just once!

About the Author

Dan McFeely is a Carmel, Indiana, writer, communications business owner, book editor and a former professional journalist. Dan also works as an Adult Faith Formation Minister, currently serving as a spiritual director for the men's and women's Christ Renews His Parish program at St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic Church in Carmel. He is a graduate of the Ecclesial Lay Ministry program offered by the Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana and has studied theology at Marian University.

Author Archive Page

12 Comments

  1. Thank you Dan for the beautiful reflection. i would like to know whether God telling Moses to “order” the rock to bring forth water is the same as tapping it once instead of twice as you have said. I was thinking God was just telling Moses to speak to the rock so water could flow from it but Moses chose his own way of tapping it twice. Therein lies his punishment i.e. choosing his way instead of that of God.

    …Then the glory of the LORD appeared to them,
    and the LORD said to Moses,
    “Take your staff and assemble the community,
    you and your brother Aaron,
    and in their presence order the rock to yield its waters.
    From the rock you shall bring forth water for the congregation
    and their livestock to drink.”
    So Moses took his staff from its place before the LORD, as he was ordered.
    He and Aaron assembled the community in front of the rock,
    where he said to them, “Listen to me, you rebels!
    Are we to bring water for you out of this rock?”
    Then, raising his hand, Moses struck the rock twice with his staff,

  2. Dan, I always thought as you when reading this. However today I thought of something else as I was reading it. Moses made it sound like he was performing some kind of magic trick. I’m probably way off, but that was my thought.

  3. Thanks. We have always trid to figure out why one extra tap was such a big deal. Now it makes sense.

  4. I never realised it was the double tap that got Moses into this… Thank you for enlightening me…
    I always have a faith crisis.. always!

  5. The other afternoon, I had a chance to visit my old stomping grounds at Glen Miller Park to get water from a spring fountain. I brought a friend with me and showed her and had her taste the water. I did too and loved how it stayed the same, nice, cold, fresh just like it did when I was a kid. The trip to Glen Miller Park was a great memory trip, especially when a good friend is with you to share and witness. I am reminded, those who thirst, come to me…My God, how I love thee!!!!!

  6. Dan, thank you for helping me to understand this passage. I see now that Moses did not glorify God, instead of telling the community that the rock would bring forth water from God in response to their cries. Today, I see the lack of faith in his words, “Are we to bring water for you out of this rock?” It must have really hurt and angered God to see Moses lose faith after they had built such a close relationship where He had proven Himself so many times.

  7. Indeed the walk of faith is our personal walk with Jesus. Sometimes I get it right, and sometimes I get it wrong. I can only try to let my faith lead more of the time.
    Thanks for sharing Dan. Blessings to you and your family.

  8. Hey Dan,

    Put yourself in the shoes of Moses. Your told to do something, you do it and nothing happens. What would you do? What would be your train of thought?

    How many times have you gone into a room, hit the light switch and nothing happens? What’s the first thing you do? In my case, I’d try flipping the switch a few more times. In other words, something is wrong and I’m trying to figure out why. The first thought that comes to mind is I did something wrong not that the power company has a problem.

    As we read through the Bible, there are many instances that the “punishment doesn’t fit the crime”. My favorite is when the arc of the covenant is being transported and Uzzah goes to steady it because it is starting to fall and, zap! God strikes Uzzah dead on the spot. (2 Samuel 6).

    On the surface God appears to punish Man for what we would consider a natural ingrained reflex, hit the rock until something happens or catch a falling precious object, but as you pointed out, dig a little deeper.

    God is just.

    Mark

  9. Dan,

    Thank you for your reflection. I meant to send you my comment in the morning, but got distracted at work.

    Could you please clarify why you feel that God had instructed Moses to “tap the rock”? What God stated was, “Take your staff and assemble the community, you and your brother Aaron, and in their presence order [or ‘command’] the rock to yield its waters.”

    Based on what is written, God did not order or command Moses to “tap” or even “strike” the rock. What is clear, however, is that God instructed Moses to “order” the rock to yield its waters i.e. make a verbal command. The fact that God instructed Moses to take his staff with him doesn’t mean that he wanted Moses to tap or strike the rock. As Moses was the leader and he was to gather his people, it appears that the staff was required in order for him to truly project himself as the leader while making the verbal command.

    Either way you look at this, God was angry with Moses for not following his instructions. I am interested in understanding why you feel God wanted Moses to “tap” the rock.

    Again, thank you and God bless.

  10. Dear all, Moses had in the past used the staff to split the sea etc. My thinking is that God already had a way of using Moses through the staff to perform his instructions. Your take.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.