Thursday, June 27, 2019 – Abraham, Ishmael & Isaac

Today’s first reading from Genesis is a little shocking to our 21st Century senses.

Here we have a guy in his 80s who is desperate to produce an heir – a son – to carry on his name (as had been promised by the voice we now recognize as God).

Abram and Sarai were frustrated that they had not been able to conceive a child. So, Sarai comes up with a plan to produce a son through one of her servants, Hagar. She “gives” Hagar to Abram and they get down to business.

Of course, this would not fly today. Such an arrangement would cause quite the scandal. However, we must try to NOT apply our current sense of right vs. wrong when reading these Old Testament stories. Those were different times, servants (slaves) were seen and treated differently and the quest for children, particularly boys, was quite a bit different from today’s contraceptive mentality.

Sarai’s plan worked, sort of, and Abram suddenly had a child named Ishmael.  But there was no happy ending for Hagar and her son. Sarai gets jealous and begins to mistreat Hagar, who flees into the desert.

Meanwhile, God finally comes through with a son for Sarai – and after a name change, Sarah and Abraham now have Isaac, who would be the son through which an entire nation of people would emerge – ie, Judaism and eventually,  Christianity.

But what of Ishmael?

Banished to the desert, God reaches out to them through an angel and promises that he will protect them so that another nation might emerge through Ishmael – ie, Islam.

This is why we call Abraham the Father of many faiths – at least the three biggies, the monotheistic (one God) faiths that have spread across the globe.

It would be easy to read today’s first reading and come away with the feeling that the present-day divisions between Jews, Christians and Muslims can be traced back to the way Sarah treated Hagar and how Abraham allowed his first son to be banished from the family.

But … I would challenge us to look at it a bit differently.

Yes, there were problems and issues, especially after Hagar and Ishmael rejoined the family for a while. We really don’t know how Ishmael and his little brother Isaac got a long … all we can glean from Scripture is that Sarah continued to feel threatened by the presence of both Ishmael and his mother, Hagar.

Perhaps it was God’s will to allow those feelings to once again split the family and send the oldest boy and his mother back out to the desert. (Or perhaps this part of Genesis was the way the Old Testament storytellers explained why there were divisions among the people who seemed to worship the same God.)

You should continue to read deeper into this story, where you will learn that Abraham stayed in contact with Ishmael and when he finally passed away at the age of 175, both of his boys joined together to bury their father.

While it is apparent that the two quickly split again and both became tools in the hand of God to create many nations … the modern-day concept that there are too many differences among Jews, Christians and Muslims to ever hope for peace has gained worldwide acceptance.

I choose to believe otherwise.

We must never give up on the hope for peace all over the world. As hard as it might be, we must remember that men (and women) do horrible things in the name of what they believe is their religion, or what they feel God would have them do. In other words, they often serve to corrupt the rest of the world’s perception of their faith, based on their acts that may have actually been prompted for other reasons.

Hatred among faiths is often sparked and perpetuated by misunderstandings and the “fake news and views” spread across the land.

Personally, I know many faithful Jews and Muslims who would agree with today’s Psalm

Give thanks to the LORD, for he is good, for his mercy endures forever.

Who can tell the mighty deeds of the LORD, or proclaim all his praises?

Blessed are they who observe what is right, who do always what is just.

Remember us, O LORD, as you favor your people.

Visit me with your saving help, that I may see the prosperity of your chosen ones,

rejoice in the joy of your people, and glory with your inheritance.

In today’s Gospel, Jesus gives us another morsel of truth to chew on …

Jesus said to his disciples:

“Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the Kingdom of heaven, but only the one who does the will of my Father in heaven.

Many will say to me on that day, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name? Did we not drive out demons in your name? Did we not do mighty deeds in your name?’ Then I will declare to them solemnly, ‘I never knew you. Depart from me, you evildoers.’

“Everyone who listens to these words of mine and acts on them will be like a wise man who built his house on rock.”

As we move about this crazy and confusing world, my prayer is that we draw closer to God in everything that we do and look at our brothers and sisters – no matter their religion or culture – and recognize them for what they truly are – creations of the same God who created us.

Worthy of our love, our respect and our forgiveness.

About the Author

Dan McFeely is a Carmel, Indiana, writer, communications business owner, book editor and a former professional journalist. Dan also works as an Adult Faith Formation Minister, currently serving as a spiritual director for the men's and women's Christ Renews His Parish program at St. Elizabeth Ann Seton Catholic Church in Carmel. He is a graduate of the Ecclesial Lay Ministry program offered by the Diocese of Lafayette-in-Indiana and has studied theology at Marian University.

Author Archive Page

8 Comments

  1. Thank you Dan for a good understanding of the first reading and how it applies to the modern world. I join you in your prayer for a more peaceful world. One God says it all. Peace be will all of us.

  2. We are to live by the lessons in scripture???
    This story from Genesis is an odd juxtaposition. Lineage is important, but perhaps too much detail. Such behaviors, generally, are considered our damnation. And to be followed in the gospel with a message of explicitly doing God’s will. I am torn. Reconciliation is elusive.

  3. Excellent reflection, Dan. Very thought provoking. It’s hard to imagine what life was like in that time and how important it was to have children. It seems the division created between Sarai and Hagar continues today with all the negative emotions. Hopefully God has a plan for healing this great divide.

  4. First thing I thought of was May Pang (Hagar), Yoko Ono (Sarah), and John Lennon (Abraham). The goal was not to have children, but the story follows a similar plotline. Then I thought of Julie Young, a writer for this website, who will surely get my reference.

    Everybody who isn’t familiar with this story, look it up if you have time.

  5. Dan, you said “I choose to believe otherwise”. How do you explain Matthew 10:34-36?
    From what I understand, we’ll always have division.

  6. I have learned from my scripture studies, from reading religious commentaries, that we should never take a verse such as Matt. 10:34 as a stand alone for discussion. One needs to read the passages before and after to understand what Jesus was trying to impart. As well, one should never translate scripture literally.

    Jesus never wielded a sword against anyone, nor does he order his followers to swing one either. Remember Jesus told Peter to put away his sword when he cut off the ear of Malchus. He is saying a true disciple who comes from a possibly hostile family has to use a SWORD OF THE WILL (never a physical sword) to sever away all opposition.

    Jesus says a spiritual sword, not a physical one, may sever family ties, so his disciples must be ready for that. How many of us have had discussions about what the bible says, got into an argument, got angry and so on. We start to take sides. Families become divided, stop talking to each other and so on.

    Jesus uses the word sword metaphorically because it is the sharpest of all weapons. It is the emblem of the right of authority, the sword of (impartiality) justice. The Word of God, we may remember, is likened to a sword (Eph. 6:17, Heb. 4:12);

    Here are few other places were the symbol of the sword is used:

    The sword of Christ is: (1) a sword of separation, (2) the word of God (Ephesians 6:17; Hebrews 4:12), (3) the sword of authority (Romans 13:1-8), (4) the sword of judgment (Genesis 3:24), (5) the sword of correction (Revelation 2:16), and (6) the sword of victory (Revelation 19:13). Even Mary, the mother of Jesus, was acquainted with that sword. “Yea, and a sword shall pierce thine own soul” (Luke 2:55).

    The Gospel is such a penetrating message that it acts like a “sword”. It pierces the consciences of humanity and calls us to love God more than we love ourselves.

    ????????????
    Blessings
    ………………………………………………………………………
    Thou hast given me so much. Give me one more thing – A Grateful Heart. – George Herbert

  7. Chris, I get it “a spiritual sword”. However, the world and the 3 major religions will not know peace. I do have a Muslim friend and he’s a great person. Yes, we both can agree on one God the father almighty. He says the Muslims have 90 + factions of Islam. How many fractions of Christianity are there? Over 2 thousand from what I’ve read.
    Anyway, not looking for an argument only stating from what I understand.
    Peace be with you

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.